| Philipp Hofmann Centre-Forward | 15/16 | 1.FC Kaiserslautern Brentford FC | 30 | 17/18 | | 9 | 709 |
| Mikael Ishak Centre-Forward | 13/14 | 1.FC Köln Parma Calcio 1913 | 7 | 16/17 | | 46 | 1.273 |
| Reinhold Yabo Central Midfield | 15/16 | Karlsruher SC Red Bull Salzburg | 62 | 16/17 | | 53 | 568 |
| Albert Bunjaku Centre-Forward | 14/15 | 1.FC Kaiserslautern FC St. Gallen 1879 | 31 | 16/17 | | 23 | 926 |
| Taner Yalçın Defensive Midfield | 12/13 | 1.FC Köln Basaksehir FK | 0 | 16/17 | | 1 | 1.534 |
| Rouwen Hennings Second Striker | 15/16 | Karlsruher SC Burnley FC | 60 | 16/17 | | 152 | 374 |
| Clemens Fandrich Central Midfield | 15/16 | RB Leipzig FC Luzern | 8 | 16/17 | | 166 | 366 |
| Karim Matmour Right Winger | 15/16 | 1.FC Kaiserslautern Al-Arabi SC (Kuwait) | 56 | 16/17 | | 13 | 366 |
| Barış Özbek Central Midfield | 14/15 | 1.FC Union Berlin Kayserispor | 40 | 15/16 | | 9 | 385 |
| Denis Thomalla Attacking Midfield | 15/16 | RB Leipzig Lech Poznan | 3 | 15/16 | | 173 | 195 |
| Davidson Eden Centre-Back | 12/13 | FC St. Pauli Esbjerg fB | 15 | 15/16 | | 2 | 1.153 |
| Daniel Davari Goalkeeper | 14/15 | Eintracht Braunschweig Grasshopper Club Zurich | 59 | 15/16 | | 9 | 365 |
| Domi Kumbela Centre-Forward | 14/15 | Eintracht Braunschweig Kardemir Karabükspor | 62 | 15/16 | | 6 | 364 |
| Nick Proschwitz Centre-Forward | 12/13 | SC Paderborn 07 Hull City | 33 | 15/16 | | 19 | 1.078 |
| Rodnei Centre-Back | 12/13 | 1.FC Kaiserslautern Red Bull Salzburg | 34 | 14/15 | | 6 | 884 |
| Stanislav Sestak Centre-Forward | 11/12 | VfL Bochum MKE Ankaragücü | 0 | 14/15 | | 27 | 1.119 |
| Eke Uzoma Left-Back | 12/13 | TSV 1860 Munich Pécsi MFC | 8 | 13/14 | | 1 | 543 |
| Halil Altıntop Attacking Midfield | 11/12 | Eintracht Frankfurt Trabzonspor | 0 | 13/14 | | 0 | 731 |
| John Jairo Mosquera Centre-Forward | 11/12 | 1.FC Union Berlin Changchun Yatai | 79 | 12/13 | | 14 | 333 |
| Ronald Gercaliu Centre-Back | 11/12 | FC Ingolstadt 04 LKS Lodz | 0 | 12/13 | | 9 | 136 |
| Zafer Yelen Attacking Midfield | 09/10 | FC Hansa Rostock Trabzonspor | 28 | 11/12 | | 67 | 729 |
| Marc Pfertzel Right-Back | 10/11 | VfL Bochum AO Kavala | 3 | 11/12 | | 87 | 168 |
| Klemen Lavric Centre-Forward | 08/09 | MSV Duisburg Omiya Ardija | 29 | 11/12 | | 31 | 1.095 |
| Mustafa Kucukovic Centre-Forward | 08/09 | TSV 1860 Munich Grenoble Foot 38 | 29 | 11/12 | | 5 | 882 |
| Stefan Maierhofer Centre-Forward | 08/09 | SpVgg Greuther Fürth Rapid Vienna | 10 | 10/11 | | 27 | 762 |